Which scenario is NOT an example of an open skill

Which scenario is NOT an example of an open skill

• A. Shooting a free throw in a quiet gym
• B. Dribbling during a fast break
• C. Hitting in baseball with fielders nearby
• D. Dribbling under defensive pressure during a game

Answer: (A)

Open skills are actions done in dynamic, unpredictable environments where you must continually adapt to others’ movements and changing conditions. Closed skills happen in stable, predictable settings with minimal external variation. Shooting a free throw in a quiet gym fits a closed skill. The environment is controlled: no defenders, little distraction, and a consistent routine. You can perform the technique with little need to adjust to others, so it’s not an open skill. The other scenarios require reacting to moving opponents and changing play conditions, which is characteristic of open skills. Dribbling during a fast break involves adjusting to teammates’ and opponents’ positions and the fast pace. Dribbling under defensive pressure requires responding to a defender’s actions in real time. Hitting in baseball with fielders nearby adds pressure and variability from both the pitcher and the fielders’ positioning. These require ongoing adaptation, so they are open skills. Therefore, the scenario that is NOT an open skill is shooting a free throw in a quiet gym.

Open skills are actions done in dynamic, unpredictable environments where you must continually adapt to others’ movements and changing conditions. Closed skills happen in stable, predictable settings with minimal external variation.

Shooting a free throw in a quiet gym fits a closed skill. The environment is controlled: no defenders, little distraction, and a consistent routine. You can perform the technique with little need to adjust to others, so it’s not an open skill.

The other scenarios require reacting to moving opponents and changing play conditions, which is characteristic of open skills. Dribbling during a fast break involves adjusting to teammates’ and opponents’ positions and the fast pace. Dribbling under defensive pressure requires responding to a defender’s actions in real time. Hitting in baseball with fielders nearby adds pressure and variability from both the pitcher and the fielders’ positioning. These require ongoing adaptation, so they are open skills.

Therefore, the scenario that is NOT an open skill is shooting a free throw in a quiet gym.